Our Boundaries, Their Growth: When Parents Say ‘Will Not’ vs. ‘Cannot’

التعليقات · 16 الآراء

This blog seeks to define PDA; what it means for autism, how it occurs in children, and why drawing boundaries with compassion - knowing when something is true 'cannot' versus firm 'will not' - can help both parent and child grow.

Parenting a child on the autism spectrum has a lot of nuances. There is a tightrope between encouraging independence and self-confidence on one side and the realities of various complications which include sensory sensitivities, anxiety, and unique responses to daily demands on the other. Of all these behavioral patterns that most parents are likely to encounter, Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA) seems to stand out mostly as being widely misunderstood.

This blog seeks to define PDA; what it means for autism, how it occurs in children, and why drawing boundaries with compassion - knowing when something is true 'cannot' versus firm 'will not' - can help both parent and child grow.

What is Pathological Demand Avoidance?

Pathological Demand Avoidance (PDA) is a profile seen in autistic children and adults. It is characterized by extreme avoidance of everyday demands and expectations, even the simple ones. Unlike typical acts of refusal, this isn't stubbornness or bad behavior; it's driven by anxiety, a deep need for control, and fear of losing autonomy.

For instance:

  • A parent says, "Please put on your shoes." The laugh is nervous and distracts the child or outright refuses.
  • A teacher requests, "Open your notebook." The child may hide under the desk or create diversion.
  • Not signs of laziness, this is their struggle with the overwhelming pressure of requirements.

The Difference Between Cannot and Will Not

And this is where the real importance of the parent comes in. Identifying a behavior source to be either a real "cannot" or a "will not" helps you in categorizing what it is and, therefore, the correct response.

Cannot: The child really cannot do it currently, and that could be because of anxiety, sensory overload, or maybe executive functioning challenges. For example, a child with PDA may "cannot" do a request because it feels like an unbearable demand.

Will Not: This is quite a conscious boundary or choice usually laid by the parent. For example, one may say, "I will not allow you extra screen time tonight since we need to prepare for bed."

When parents continually model healthy boundaries (will not), children learn resiliency and structure. They cannot understand. They are empathetic and supportive, creating less stress and anxiety.

Signs of Pathological Demand Avoidance

The following are designations that parents make for their children who have PDA:

✔️ Extremely resistant to ordinary requests

✔️ Using distraction, excuses, or role-play to avoid demands

✔️ Very good at understanding social rules yet still suffering from demands or very good at understanding social rules but still having demands

✔️ Sudden mood swings when required to do anything

✔️ Controlling play or interaction

Knowing these signs is how families strategize without mistaking avoidance for defiance.

Strategies for Assisting Children with PDA

To support a child with Pathological Demand Avoidance, one must be flexible, creative, and above all, patient. Here are some practical approaches:

Reduce Direct Demands

Rephrase from "Put your shoes on now": 

? "Which shoe do you want to wear first—this one or that one?"

Choice reduces pressure while still achieving the goal.

Use Team 

Present tasks as working as a team: 

? "Let's tidy up together. You pick up the blocks, and I will grab the books."

Furthermore, give predictability because:

Children with PDA flourish when routines are clear and flexibly softened expectations: Visual schedules, or even simple routines, can reduce anxiety.

Keep Calm During Resistance

An avoidance is met with a calm, patient tone instead of escalating the situation to add pressure on the child.

Reward Mini Milestones

Recognizing even the most pitiful attempts at cooperating-such as donning one shoe-helps to balance the gain long-term. 

Why Boundaries Still Matter

There must be empathy and limits. Children will feel secure since avoidance won't be a practice, but they would also lose an opportunity to develop coping skills. Openness and balance are key in this one:

  • Respect the child's moments of "cannot" - that would be anxiety or PDA driven. 
  • Hold up the parent's "will not" rules keeping in place structure, safety, and growth. 

Boundaries form trust. They teach the child that, as much as there is understanding about their challenges, there are things in life that have non-negotiable limits-bedtime, health routines, or safety rules. 

A Journey of Growth 

For a parent with a child with Pathological Demand Avoidance, winning wars is not the goal; rather, it's building trust, reducing anxiety, and guiding growth through empathy joined to structure. Parents are instructed to differentiate between "cannot" and "will not." Thus, children gain supporting strategies to meet their individual needs, while parents model resilience and flexibility with self-respect. 

At Rachna Autism Care, we believe that every child is capable of achieving through understanding and operative strategies. And with this balance of compassion and balanced authority, parents can rekindle the courage in their children to face the challenge one step at a time.

 

التعليقات